A rose is a rose is a rose, except when it is not. A Harold Davis rose photo is apparently a Georgia O’Keeffe rose painting when you search Google Images for “Georgia O’Keeffe” (opens in a separate window, may be a number of rows down) except when it is actually Kiss from a Rose by Harold Davis (shown below). I’m really pretty flattered by the association, as Georgia O’Keeffe is certainly one of my great artistic heroes.
Kiss from a Rose © Harold Davis
I was alerted to my photo made in homage to O’Keeffe being mistaken for a literal O’Keefe by a reader who wrote, “Hi Harold! Love your Rose Photography. I see on Google your work is confused with Georgia O’Keeffe’s paintings!” While this case of mistaken artistic identity mostly involves Kiss from a Rose, some of my other images such as Eye of the Rose and even the book cover for my Photographing Flowers also occasionally show up categorized as O’Keeffe’s.
The conflation of Harold Davis photos with Georgia O’Keeffe paintings get even more pronounced on Pinterest, where a number of “boards” have “pinned” my image as a Georgia O’Keeffe’s. See www.pinterest.com/terper1234/georgia-o-keeffe/ (my rose is called “a lush red O’Keeffe”) and www.pinterest.com/nicolenotch/artist-o-keefe/ (once again my rose is ascribed to O’Keeffe).
2 Comments
When I was a graduate student in mathematical logic many long years ago, I once walked into my adviser’s office and found written on his blackboard:
“”A rose is a rose” is a rose” is a sentence of the English language and is false.
For an intelligent discussion of Pinterest as a facilitator of copyright violation see greekgeek.hubpages.com/hub/Is-Pinterest-a-Haven-for-Copyright-Violations
3 Trackbacks
[…] « When is a Harold Davis rose a Georgia O’Keeffe? […]
[…] Related story: When is a Harold Davis rose a Georgia O’Keeffe? […]
[…] Related story: When is a Harold Davis rose a Georgia O’Keeffe? […]